TIGblogs TIG | TIGblogs GROUP TIGBLOGS LOGIN SIGNUP
Random Thoughts & Poetry of Praba
Random Thoughts & Poetry of Praba
« previous 10


Regional Educational Imbalance
Related to country: India
Translations available in: English (original) | French | Spanish | Italian | German | Portuguese | Swedish | Russian | Dutch | Arabic

Regional Educational Imbalance

The southern and western states are in the forefront of educational development in India. Now it is reaching such a flashpoint that higher educational institutes are popping up everywhere. Is this going to create heavy migration of students?


Hemali Chhapla writes in The Times of India “A common wisecrack among engineering aspirants in Andra Pradesh is that every second building in the state is an engineering college. It may cease to be a joke when institutes dishing out management and engineering degrees start mushrooming all over the country.

Global depression may have taken the wind out of campus placements but the rush for starting professional institutions is at an all time high. Data from the All-India Council for Technical Education (AICTE) shows that the dash to start professional colleges is more pronounced when it comes to engineering and management as compared to other streams like pharmacy, hotel management and catering technology or architecture.

AICTE has received 886 applications for starting engineering colleges and 1,084 applications for new anagement institutes. Fie states – Tamil Nadu, Andra Pradesh, Maharastra, Karnataka and Kerala – account for 69% of engineering graduates , implying that they also have most of India’s engineering colleges

Rush year
States Engineering MBA
Existing Fresh Existing Fresh
Maharashtra 239 85 216 160
MP 161 50 63 80
Tamil Nadu 352 144 158 41
AP 527 176 255 209
UP 241 83 213 214
Haryana 116 38 66 47
Across India 2388 886 1516 1084

Source: AICTE. Fresh applications are for colleges from academic year 2009-10

Five Indian sties – Tamil Nadu, Andra Pradesh, Maharashtra, Karnataka and Kerala – account for almost 69% of the country’s engineering graduates, implying that these states also have most of India’s engineering colleges.

This year, too, most applications for starting new institutes have come from these states, making educationists worry about a high regional imbalance creepin in; states like UP, Bihar, Gujarat, Rajasthan and Orissa together account for a measly 14% of Indian’s technological colleges.

Colleges that receive a nod by June 30 will be allowed to start classes this academic year itself; so officials expect even more applications to pour in.

Several academicians feel quality is losing out in the race to expand seats. “Can the country boast of even 100 engineering colleges that impart cutting-edge education?” asked a principal of Pune engineering college.
“So what is the point in a thousand new colleges every year? He asked. Part of the problem lies in the fact that most trusts running professional colleges are backed by politicians who pay little attention to quality, he added.

But the AICTE feels that meeting the massive demand for professional education is imperative. Twenty years ago, merely one per cent of a aspiring engineers got a seat.
Now nearly 70% manage to find a place, note AICTE officials, “It may come as a surprise but very few engineering seats wee left vacant last year”. AICTE chairman R.A.Yadav told TOI. “There is also a yawning gap between management aspirants and the number of seats in Indian B-schools.

“But how many management schools boast of full campus placement? And are even 30% of MBA institutes accredited by the NBA (National Board of Accreditation) asked an IIM-Bangalore faculty member.

Increasing the existing number of professional colleges is a must. In a view of the galloping population and raising educational aspirations of people more availability of higher educational institutes are must. But not by compromising the quality of the education offered.

February 19, 2009 | 1:07 AM Comments  0 comments


Spiceless Interim Budget
Related to country: India
Translations available in: English (original) | French | Spanish | Italian | German | Portuguese | Swedish | Russian | Dutch | Arabic

Guesses were in the air. Whether Pranab Mukherjee, the acting Prime Minister and finance minister will unveil a voter populist interim budget? Contrary to the popular expectations he just presented the economic scenario and expenditure statement. In the past most of the heavy loaded interim budgets got backfired. The government which presented voter-centric interim budgets got defeated. This may be the dampener on the UPA dispensation. Nevertheless the politics of budget presentation was much stronger than any astrological calculations.

Sudipto Mundle writes in The Times of India (17.2.2009, p.20), reacting to the great bull run in US markets a few years ago, Allan Greenspan famously remarked that the market displayed ‘irrational exuberance’. Today it is tempting to misquote Greenspan that our our markets are suffering from ‘irrational pessimism’. The sensex dropped by about 3 per cent and the Nifty too headed down, while Pranab Mukherjee was still reading his Budget speech.

The Interim Budget is more a stock taking, along with expenditure proposals for parliamentary approval to keep the government running till the regular Budget by the next government. But even in such an exercise, which is by design underwhelming, there are a few important points worth noting. We had hoped in these columns earlier, as had others, that the government would temporarily shelve the Fiscal Responsibility and Budget Management (FRBM) Act. This has been done. The government has provided a huge fiscal stimulus during the fiscal 2008-09 amounting to over Rs.1,93,000 crore or 4.5 per cent of GDP over and above what was envisaged in last year’s Budget, which already provided for a deficit of over Rs.1,33,000 crore.

The true fiscal stimulus must include not only what was announced under the two packages in December 208 and January 2009, but also the expenditure under the two supplementary demands for grants approved by Parliament last September and December. It is another matter that these supplementary demands made up for the creative under provisioning of some known items of expenditure in last year’s Budget to remain within the fiscal parameters of the FRBM. The total consolidated deficit for 2008-09, including the actual budget deficit of the central government (6 per cent), the state governments (3.5 per cent) and some off-budget items such as the additional contingent liability for oil and fertilizer bonds (1.8 per cent), amounts to over 11.5 per cent of GDP or nearly Rs.6,26,000 crore.

It is this massive fiscal stimulus combined with sustained monetary stimulus measures from the RBI, that have kept the Indian economy chugging along at 6-7 per cent growth, even as most of the developed world has gone into a deep recession. It has also helped to arrest the free fall of stock market and the depreciation of the rupee. Conventional wisdom suggests that to be successful, such stimulus packages have to be timely, targeted and temporary. With these measures having come within a few weeks of the collapse of Lehman Brothers in September 2008, and with much of the stimulus directed at the worst affected sectors – exports, infrastructure, real estate, transport – the government and the central bank have clearly passed the first two tests.

But what does the Interim Budget have to tell us about the future? It provides for a central government deficit of 5.5 per cent in 2009-10, though Mukherjee indicated that this could rise by a further 1 per cent. Adding to that 3.5 per cent deficit of state governments, and possibly some further off-budget provisions, 2009-10 could also end up with a massive deficit of 10-11 per cent. Coming on top of the huge stimulus this year, this could indeed go a long way in pump priming demand, compensating for the loss in export demand from developed countries. Moreover, much of the additional spending is targeted at infrastructure, employment programmes and education and health programmes.

However, the question is how this massive deficit will be financed. The large government borrowing this year has crowded out the private sector. This is why interest-rates have not come down substantially, and banks are still shy of lending to private borrowers despite all the policy measures taken by the RBI. If next year’s deficit too is to be financed by market borrowing, that could be bad news for the private sector, and severely put at risk the recovery of private investment.

It is important, therefore, that a large part of the deficit be monetized .e financed by government borrowing from the RBI which prevents RBI financing of government deficits. The finance secretary did indicate that something of this kind may be in the offing. Low inflation minimizes the risk of inflationary pressures arising from the consequent increase in money supply. The shelving of the FRBM and the putting on hold of the MoU with RBI would set aside the two key anchors of prudence that have guided fiscal policy in recent years However, exceptional times require exceptional measures.

That being, said, it has to be added that abandoning fiscal prudence is fraught with risk, as we have learned to our cost in the past. Hence the third test of the stimulus, that it must be temporary. The fiscal and monetary stimuli are like major shocks being applied now to revive the economy. Research shows that the lag generated by such shocks being applied now to revive the economy.

Research shows that the lag generated by such shocks can last for years, making the recover itself fragile. It is imperative that the fiscal and monetary breaks be applied as soon as the economy returns to a high growth path. As Mukherjee indicated, strong fiscal and monetary compression, return to the FRBM regime and the MoU with RBI must remain high priorities. Hopefully, recovery will occur by 2010, so the fiscal consolidation can be initiated within the first half of the next government’s tenure, before the compulsions of the next electoral cycle take over.

Wisely the UPA government had presented the economic scenario as the interim budget. Without stirring the hornet’s nest it has moved to face the electoral battle. It is true that major decisions can be announced few days before the election code of conduct comes into force. In that sense one has wait for the last minute to see the government’s mood to restructure the economy. Anyway, decision without many controversies affecting public lives with adequate coalition arithmetic can win elections. One can assume that the government is steering the no controversy ship rather than high pro activity with controversies. This cool and calm may win another term for UPA not its ability to put the economy on the high speed track.

February 17, 2009 | 4:13 AM Comments  0 comments


Slow Down Life
Translations available in: English (original) | French | Spanish | Italian | German | Portuguese | Swedish | Russian | Dutch | Arabic

Everyone is in a hurry. No one knows where they are heading. This speed breaker free world is dangerous. Money, career, achievements, promotions ----- there is no end to the human desires. But at the end of the day those high end chasers are not happy. They are anywhere and everywhere but without happiness. After the recession they have added financial worry to their kitty of troubles. Are we in the right direction?

Sadhu Vishwamurtidas writes in The Times of India (17.2.2009 p.20)“ The best of countries and corporations are so because they have the best of budgets. Hence the concern over the national budget. However, if people spent as much time worrying about their domestic budget as they did about the national one, globally, things would be different. How many focus inwards to analyse how exactly they have budgeted their own hard-earned money.

Many of us continue to spend well beyond our income, inviting debts. Bhagwan Swaminarayan advises in his Shikshapatri, “One should keep a daily record of one’s expenditure and income and should always live within one’s means. All of us, rich or poor, should give something to charity”.

Still fewer people have worked out a ‘life’ budget for themselves. A life budget includes committing time to self, family, society and God. The lives of those who do this get enriched not just financially, but also socially and spiritually.

Many corporate executives invest all their time and effort in pursuing their careers and climbing the professional ladder. It is at all worthwhile? Most discover that their victory is empty and that they won it at an irreparable loss to their health, family and psyche, incurring obesity, heart disease and fatigue on the physiological front; separated spouse, estranged children and uncared-for-parents on the familial front; frustration, depression and stress on the physio-psychological front.

In many societies, this phenomenon has resulted in a tragic burgeoning of societies and cardiovascular and cancer-related deaths. The Royal bank of Canada devoted one of its monthly letters to this problem with the title, “Let’s Slow Down’, “we are victims of mounting tensions”, it enunciated. “We have difficulty relaxing: we are not living fully”.

For many in India too, life has taken on these contours, and living it is rather like going downhill in a truck without brakes. But it is still not too late. The World Health Organisation (WHO) predicts that stress will be the Number One killer in the world by 2020. And stress is usually nothing more than an individual’s failure to balance his lifestyle.

Living life is a healthy manner and living it fully means we have to maintain regular food habits and follow a sensible diet, regular exercise and rest, going out with family, working for charity and spending some time in reflection, mediation and prayer.

There is only one way to survive overwork or burnout. Be brave and bailout or you will be a loser. Life’s rat race only produces losers. It has no winners. Even if it does, the winner is still a rat. And usually a very large one.

A sage asked a prosperous king, “If you were about to die of thirst and starvation and someone offered you a glass of water and a loaf of bread in exchange for your wealth and kingdom, would you give them to him?” “of course I would”, replied the king. “Anybody would”. “then why”, asked the sage, “have you wasted your entire life amassing all this land and wealth when they are worth no more to you than a glass of water and a loaf of bread?”

Human life is priceless. God has bequeathed this limitless treasure trove to all. And as diversification is one of the secrets to successful investment, so is it the secret to a joyous and blessed life. Reach into your soul, and reach out to your family, society and God. Budget well.

Fast driving on the lifeway without control over the vehicle amounts to suicidal attempt. No one’s live is a straight line. Ups and downs are normal. There is no prediction or forecast which can help us to avoid. Crisis and cyclone can come without prior warning. Knowing this one should slow down and take time out to read the bold signals on the sides. Calm going can help to get rid of the bad consequences and make life ha

February 17, 2009 | 4:10 AM Comments  0 comments


Different ways of polluting
Translations available in: English (original) | French | Spanish | Italian | German | Portuguese | Swedish | Russian | Dutch | Arabic

There is not a single culprit in the climate change crisis who wants to mend their ways. Every day new pollutants are emerging with more dangerous contributions. From electronic junks to eating habits air, water, soil and other essential common properties are damaged. In this nature destructive game advanced countries are the real villains.

The Times of India (16.2.2009) writes “When it comes to global warming, hamburgers are the real Hummers of food, scientists say. Simply switching from steak to salad could cut as much carbon as leaving the car at home a couple days a week. That’s because beef is such an incredibly inefficient food to produce and cows release so much harmful methane into the atmosphere, said Nathan Pelletier of Dalhousie University in Canada.

The livestock sector is estimated to account for 18% of the global greenhouse gas emissions and beef is the biggest culprit. Even though beef only accounts for 30% of meat consumption in the developed world it’s responsible for 78% of the emissions, Pelletier, said.

That’s because a single kilogram of beef produces 16 killograms carbon dioxide equivalent emissions: four times higher than pork and more than ten times as much as a kilogram of poultry. Pelletier said. If people were to simply switch from beef to chicken, emissions would be cut by 70%, Pelletier said.

Another part of the problem is people are eating far more meat than they need to. “Meat once was a luxury in our diet,” Pelletier said. “we used to eat it once a week. Now we eat it every day.”

If meat consumption in the developed world was cut from the current level of about 90kg a year to 53kg a year, livestock related emissions would fall by 44%.

“Given the projected doubling of meat production by 2050, we’re going to have to cut emissions by half just to maintain current levels.” Pelletier said.


No one knows the consequence of beef eating. The awareness about beef and pollution should be spread intensely. Anything excess is detrimental to both people and environment. What affects personally in certain matters undermine the environment too. Unlimited beef eating is dangerous for individuals health and ecology.

February 17, 2009 | 4:05 AM Comments  0 comments


Costly justice in Delhi
Related to country: India
Translations available in: English (original) | French | Spanish | Italian | German | Portuguese | Swedish | Russian | Dutch | Arabic

Indian courts are notorious for prolonging the legal battles. People who filled petitions in their young age of 30 are not alive today to hear the final pronouncement. It takes decades for the courts to arrive at a conclusion. By the time court decides the petitioner is not alive. Due to this inordinate delay few people have faith in the judiciary. Rape, murder, property misappropriation or arson not many people would like to lodge a police complaint and seek judicial recourse. They know very well the petitioner will be harassed endlessly without any justice coming in his or her life time. The immediate help for any justice to the crime committed is underworld and criminal gangs. The instant revenge and justice are vented by these gangsters who are fully time involved in killing. If the situation is allowed to continue the judicial and police systems will lose its relevance permanently.

According to The Times of India report (11.2.2009, p.1 & 7), 3,32,141 cases came up before the Delhi High Court in 2007-08. Each of these cases received five minutes of hearing (4 minutes, 55 seconds to be precise) and each minute of the court’s time cost a staggering Rs.6,327 to the state exchequer. Even adjournements without hearing don’t come cheap. All listed cases cost the court Rs.1,300 (on average), even if many got adjourned. The report released by Chief Justice A.P. Shah, claims HC disposed of 56,612 cases, including 47,017 filled in that year alone.

While clearing 56,612 cases, Delhi High Court worked with 32 judges, much below its sanctioned strength of 48, Chief Justice A.P. Shah said. While pointing to the “Crushing load” on the courts, the Chief Justice said at present rate of disposal, it would take 466 years for the high court to clear its backlog of cases entirely. He, however said “we have been able to reduce the cases of arrears from 79,818 in 2007 to 74,599 in 2008”.

The report adds that the rate of disposal of criminal cases in the year worked out to be 0.5 case per day. While such “working ours” analyses are done every year for bodies like Parliament and state legislatures, this is perhaps the first time a judicial body has come up with its figure.

Case study
No of cases listed before HC 332,141
Total expenditure incurred Rs. 42,45,47,490
No of cases dealt on a single day 64
Total number of working days 213
Time available for one hearing 4 min 55 sec
Cost incurred for one minute of a hearing 6,327
Average number of benches during ’07-08 24(8 division & 16 single)

The time and money spent have been worked out excluding “matters handled during summer vacation (June) and on three working Saturdays during 2007-08”. In order to calculate the time judges gave for each hearing. HC factored in the total number of cases dealt by judges. Sitting as a single bench or division bench, in a day (64 cases on average) with the total time available for them to hold court (315 minutes).

The total expenditure incurred by the court last year was Rs.42.45 crore for 213 working days. “the average cost of listing each case before a judge worked out to Rs.1,297 and the average court expenditure per minute by the court was Rs.6,327 or Rs.19,93,180 for each working days.

The judiciary must ensure justice is dispensed atleast during the life time of the petitioner if not immediately. With multiple options available for reformation, courts should not delay further. Immediately it should implement all the suggested reforms. Decentralising and expanding the judiciary are two crucial steps. Above all the top leadership should have the requisite will to cleanse the system and make it functional.



February 17, 2009 | 3:56 AM Comments  0 comments
Tags:


Statistics Contradict Reality
Related to country: India
Translations available in: English (original) | French | Spanish | Italian | German | Portuguese | Swedish | Russian | Dutch | Arabic

The forecasts by economists provide feel good statistics about the economic health. But on the ground nearly two-third of the citizens feels the heat of economic crisis. They do not have enough means to sustain their lives. Inadequate food, clothing, shelter and other essentials frustrate them. Without taking common people’s living standards economic data simply bracket them into Purchasing Power Parity and bundle them into the larger GDP dimension. The result of macro definition of the economic health without fine tuning the problems on the surface twists the tale and offers it all rosy. Countries like Bhutan define human happiness index along with the GDP. It is a tiny mountainous nation with no big income. People in Bhutan are bubbling with happiness despite low incomes and no skyscrapers to boost. France is trying to redefine its economic outlook. It is high time that all nations go beyond GDP and bring out the crux of the crisis and minimize people’s problems.

Sanjeev Sanyal writes in The Times of India (10.2.2009, p.14) “The world is reeling from two major crises, the financial/economic crisis and the crisis of climate change and ecological collapse. Both are a result of the same human error, a colossal misallocation of resources, financial capital in one case and natural capital on the other. A combination of counter-cyclical policies and time will eventually get us out of the financial mess. However, climate change and catastrophic environmental degradation threaten human civilization as we know it.

Many blame globalization and capitalism for the large-scale misallocation of resources. However, isolationism and socialism provide no alternative we tried them for decades with disastrous results. A market-based system is clearly more efficient. The problem is not with the tools of capitalism but the failure to define its goals. The power of the markets is being harnessed to maximize the wrong paradigm.

The most commonly used paradigm for measuring human progress is provided by national income accounts and, more specifically gross domestic product (GDP). Virtually all economic policy-making is oriented directly or indirectly towards maximizing GDP growth. It is so ubiquitous that people forget it as an entirely artificial construct created in the 1940s as part of the war effort.

Of course, rulers from ancient times have kept some record of economic activity for taxation purposes. National accounts as we know them were created during World War II by Richard Stone and James Meade with support from John Maynard Keynes, as a way to keep track of war-time economic activity. Given the circumstances, their framework was necessarily ‘industrial’ in its essence, without space for niceties like environmental degradation and socio-demographic developments.

Post-war, this framework was adapted to create the GDP number now used. Unfortunately, the system remains an arbitrary way to measure value creation, especially in areas relating to externalities and natural capital. For instance, if we cut down a pristine rain forest we are destroying value in terms of biodiversity, watersheds, carbon sequestration, flood control, non-timber forest produce and so on. Yet, in the current system, destruction of value will show up as GDP growth from logging!

This does not mean the creators of GDP were unaware of its limitation. In his Nobel Memorial Lecture in 1984, Richard Stone stated, “The three pillars on which analysis of society ought to rest are studies of economic, socio-demographic and environmental phenomena.” He added that his work had focused mostly on economic accounting and he had not spent much time on environmental accounting even though “environmental issues, such as pollution, land use and non-renewable resources offer plenty of scope for accounting.” In short, the creators of GDP thought of it as work-in progress. Unfortunately, the world has continued to focus much of its energy on maximizing an incomplete and out-of-date paradigm.

There are ways to adjust for the short comings of GDP. One is to create additional matrices for measuring progress. The Human Development Index and Carbon Footprint are concepts that can be used to enhance the raw GDP approach. Unfortunately, they failed to gain a serious following beyond the world of activists and conferences because these measures lack the simplicity of a single GDP number.

The only real alternative then is to recalibrate GDP itself to reflect genuine value generation. This can be done by assigning monetary values to things like water pollution, deforestation, land degradation and other changes in the stock of natural capital. Similar adjustments can be made to account for changes in human capital stock (health, education etc). The result would be a new GDP number more closely reflecting true value generated by various human activities.

Economists should redefine GDP and incorporate ground situation. They should make economy fly in the air when there is no possibility of sustaining its stay on the sky. By infusing a course correction they can perform a social reengineering which is need of the hour. Poor must get the attention and priority. Simply giving the number of poor people is not sufficient. Using the latest technological prowess economists should filter down the most needy people and those in the seat of power should help those identified poor people to improve their lives. There is no alternative to this model.

February 11, 2009 | 3:56 AM Comments  0 comments


Patenting India
Related to country: India
Translations available in: English (original) | French | Spanish | Italian | German | Portuguese | Swedish | Russian | Dutch | Arabic

In the age of intellectual property rights, patenting our traditional knowledge is essential. Without patenting plagiarism will be rampant and it will affect the hard built wisdom of the age-old civilization. India has been a victim of soft pedaling patenting rights. The advanced nations with an eye on the patent rights and safeguarding its knowledge base have cleverly started patenting at an early age. As in other cases developing countries like India were dead slow in picking up patent rights. With the ball set rolling it should not stop in converting all its traditional knowledge sources into a digital form and steps must be taken to protect it from external possession and ownership.


ü India has lost over 15,000 patents of medicinal plants to the West
ü On an average, it takes 5 to 7 years to oppose a granted patent and costs between Rs 1 to 3 crores
ü Over 200,000 medical formulations have now been documented into India’s Traditional Knowledge Digital Library (TKDL)
ü Creating TKDL took over 8 years and cost Rs 7 crore
ü The library will prevent those living abroad from claiming patent for existing formulations
ü Without the library India would have lost 2000 patents every year concerning Indian Systems of Medicine (ISM)
ü At any given time, 50 patent applications based on ISMS are awaiting grant of patient
ü The decision to create TKDL was taken after wrong patents were granted on wound-healing properties of turmeric (1995) at the United States and on anti-fungal properties of Neem granted at European Patent Office (EPO)
ü The patents were revoked in 1997 and 2005 respectively
ü In the past, patents have been granted at EPO on the use of over 285 Indian medicinal plants. These include Papaya, Indian long pepper, Kali Tulsi, pudina, ginger, aloe, Isabgol, Aamla, Jira, Soyabean, Tomato, Almond, Walnut and Methi.

Over two lakh medical formulations of Ayurveda, Siddha and Unani were documented by Traditional Knowledge Digital Library (TKDL). This is an outcome of eight years of painstaking efforts by the Council of Scientific and Industrial Research (CSIR) and union health ministry’s department of Ayush. This collaborative effort has converted information of traditional Indian medicine from Hindi, Sanskrit, Arabic, Persian, Urdu and Tamil to five international languages – English, Japanese, French, German and Spanish.

All efforts must be made to dig every possible information about traditional wisdom and it must immediately digitalized and patented. This will go a long way in putting Indian knowledge on the top of global top list.

February 11, 2009 | 3:53 AM Comments  0 comments
Tags:


Increasing Mental Disorders
Related to country: India
Translations available in: English (original) | French | Spanish | Italian | German | Portuguese | Swedish | Russian | Dutch | Arabic

There are various reasons for the increasing mental disorders. One of the major factors is the negative social attitude towards the mental patients. Generally people misbehave with the mentally ill patients. The hospitals meant for these patients do not give adequate sympathy, love and care. Most of the mental patients feel better outside the hospitals. They are treated like animals in the cages. While this is the sorry state of mental health treatment in the country there is fast rise in the number of patients. Due to the severe economic crisis and lack of social support mental ill health is becoming common nowadays. The government is preparing for the worst. It must be countered with all out efforts.

WHO estimates 30 crore people globally suffer from mental health disorders
In India 15-20 crore people suffer from some sort of mental illness, the commonest being depression and anxiety syndromes, stress and psychosomatic disorders, bipolar mood disorders, schizophrenia and dementia.
1.6 of them need institutional intervention
According to WHO, at lease 3 in 4 mental health patients in developing countries receive no treatment
75% of mentally ill patients in India are treated through traditional interventions and by tantriks
8.1% of all disabilities in India are due to mental illnesses, as against 5.8% due to cancer and 4.4% due to heart diseases
India needs 32,000 psychiatrists but has 3300 trained psychiatrists, 3000 of whom are in metros
By 2020, depression is expected to become the 2nd largest illness in the world
Most countries allocate less than 2% of their health budget to mental disorders
Suicide is one of the commonest manifestations of mental illness
In India, 1.2 lakh people end their lives every year by committing suicide
4 lakh attempt commit suicide
Globally, one million people die from suicide annually
The global mortality rate is 16/100,000, or one death every 40 seconds.
In the last 45 years, suicide rates have increased by 60% worldwide
Mental disorders, particularly depression and substance abuse, are associated with more than 90% of all cases of suicide
Asia accounts for 60% of the world’s suicides
India, China and Japan account for 40% of this number
Over 71% of suicides in India are by persons below the age of 44.

The Union health ministry is getting nervous over the alarming rate of mental patients in the country. A shocking number of 13 crore Indians suffering mental disorders have shaken the ministry from its slumber. It is going to circulate a cabinet note next week to handle the rising mental disorders. It has proposed to upgrade the existing eleven mental hospitals, increase of at least 44 post-graduate seats in psychiatry, 176 M.Phil seats in clinical psychology and 220 seats for psychiatric nursing each years. The ministry envisages that 616 qualified mental health professionals would be produced from these centres. One hopes for the better situation in the coming days.

February 11, 2009 | 3:46 AM Comments  0 comments


Soaring School Fees
Related to country: India
Translations available in: English (original) | French | Spanish | Italian | German | Portuguese | Swedish | Russian | Dutch | Arabic

Private schools want freedom in deciding fees. It should be given if there is sincerity in delivering services to the public. But most of the schools are money milking machines. The over commercialization of education leaves less to desire. Human capital is the biggest source for the success of economy and society. It should be developed without compromising. Any efforts by private or public to water down the quality of education and making education unreachable for the average India should be ended immediately. It seems all the noise by the private schools about the government interference in fee decision is farce.

Manas Pratim Gohain writes in The Times of India (9.2.2009 p.2) “Schools have created a hue and cry about the “meager” fee hike of up to Rs.500 hike allowed by the government to raise teacher’s salary in line with the 6th Pay Commission proposals. But tuition fees is not the only source of income for schools – it accounts for only 35% roughly of the total expenditure that a parent incurs in sending his child to a reasonably good private school. The rest – around 65% - of school’s earning comes from transportation, uniforms, books, student welfare fund, club activities, annual day, excursions and development fund among others.

When schools determined to take their appeal for revising the hike to courts, parents are spending sleepless nights. A parent who pays tuition fee of more than Rs.2000 per month ends up paying approximately Rs.90.500 annually for transportation, school uniforms and other dresses for different fests and events organized by the school. “There are schools which charge even half yearly fees which are over and above the tuition and admission fees. We spend around Rs.1.80 lakh annually on my two kids. My husband is the only earning member and now we will have to shell out Rs.12,000 extra annually for my two kids as their tuition fee will go up Rs.500 per month,” said Monika Sharma from R.K Puram.

However schools find the government approved hike inadequate. The School Action Committee (SAC) has been meeting to discuss on fee hike of private schools in the capital on fee hike of private schools in the capital and the challenges ahead. S.K. Bhattacharya, Chairman, SAC, said: “We are going to appeal for a reconsideration on the hike. Otherwise how will the schools pay the salary of the teachers as per the 6th Pay Commission recommendation?”

Shomie Das the former headmaster of Doon School says that setting up a first-rate non-residential private school spread over a minimum of 5 acres of land for about 2,000 students would cost about Rs.30-35 crore.

“The construction cost, including the land, will lead to expenses of about Rs.25 crore. This is assuming the different buildings such as classrooms, auditoriums, and swimming pool are built over a total area of 200,000 square feet,” says Das who has helped set up 50 schools, including heritage (Kolkata) and Sanskriti (Delhi) in the past few decades.

Item Annual Payment (in Rs)
Tuition fee 6,000 -36,000
Transportation 4,800 –36,000
(School’s own transportation)
School Uniforms 3,000-4,000
Blazers* 700-1,500
Books* 3,000-4,000
Building Fund 500-1,500
Annual day 200-500
Excursion/tours 300-500
Development Fund 500-1,000
Pupil/student Fund 500,1,000
Half-yearly charge 500-1,000
Ticket Selling 500-1,000
(Given to students for selling)
Club activities 500-3,000
Festival 200-500

Total 21,200-90,500
*Shops owned or set up by schools
The list is indicative

Expensive Affair
Non-residential pvt school

• Cost of setting up a school spread over 5 acres of land for about 2,000 students Rs.30-35 crore
• Construction cost of different buildings Rs.25 crore (assuming total area is about 2 lakh sq.feet)
• Staff salaries are 70% of operational cost
• Teacher-student ratio 1:15 to 1:20

Residential school
Setting up a school over a minimum area of 20 acres Rs.75-100 crore
Construction cost Rs.50-60 crore plus the cost of land
Site development cost Rs.2-3 crore
Sports equipment, fittings Rs.5 crore
Staff salaries are 50% of operational cost
Catering expenses 30-40%
Teacher-student ratio 1:12

Keeping the crucial necessity of education for the overall development of the society, private school managements should fix their fees. Over ambition in making profit from the schools by taxing parents will lead to the large scale migration of private school students to government schools. This may create chaos and permanent deterioration of private schools financially. Better they act after analyzing the negative consequences of fee hike rather than blank demand for fee hike.